This passage has been excerpted
from Dale H. Porter, The Thames Embankment:
Environment, Technology, and Society
in Victorian London. Akron, Ohio:
University of Akron Press, 1998,
which is reviewed eleswhere in the Victorian Web GPL.
What did the Victorians like? What kind of furniture, silverwork, jewelry, wallpaper, and glass did they buy for their own homes? Even to begin to answer that question one must put the terms "Victorian" and "Victorians" within quotation marks twice -- first because the Victorian years, which lasted from 1835 (or even 1830) to 1903 or a few years beyond, obviously divides into three, four, or even five periods. Whereas the early part of Victoria's reign saw interest in a medievalor Gothick Revival in all aspects of architecture and design, much of the mid- and late-Victorian period was a time of the lush, abundant look that most of us associate with the term "Victorian." Then, from the 1880s onward, a series of reactions against High Victorian taste took place -- Aestheticism, Art Nouveau, Japonisme, the Arts and Crafts movement, the Celtic Revival and the Liberty Style, and finally Art Deco, which reached its height much later, in the 1930s and '40s. Therefore, when anyone talks about "Victorian taste," we have to find out to which part of Victoria's reign they refer.
Second and equally important, Victorian taste varied widely according to social classand the not-always-closely-related matter of economic status. To begin with, many members of the nobility and land-owning gentry, who lived in homes their families had occupied for centuries, found themselves surrounded by Elizabethan, Jacobean, and eighteenth-century furnishings, and unless they were self-consciously interested in contemporary taste, they were often unlikely to replace perfectly good furniture or silver, however old and out-of-fashion, with any examples of new taste. A conservative, prosperous, but not particularly wealthy member of the squierarchy, like Ralph Calbury of Trollope's The Way We Live Now, had no fashionable furnishings. Similarly, members of the working classes, farm workers, and unemployed poor, who together made up far more than half of the Victorian population, did not have the resources to furnish their homes with properly Victorian things.
By and large, then, questions of
Victoran taste refer primarily to the middle and professional classes,
to factory owners in the industrial North, such the Thorntons we meet in
Gaskell's North and South, and a very view wealthy trendsetters
-- the kind of people we see made the subject of Punch's mockery..
Levy, Mervyn. Liberty Style, The Classic Years, 1798-1910. New York: Abrams, 1986.
Naylor, Gillian. The Arts and
Crafts Movement: A Study of Its Sources, Ideals, and Influence on Design
Theory. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1971.