His gifts in characterization can easily be underrated. Defoe always
admires the merchant, and his
heroes are always adding up their financial profits, frequently
for Defoe's delight rather than
for the reader's pleasure.
He lacks well-Knit strucrure;
several of his stories show a break near the middle which might
suggest that Defoe has for the
moment run out of adventures, and presently must open a new
vein. When Crusoe has stablished
his economy, there is a pause; then the footprint is seen,
Friday is introduced, and we
can observe education impressing the blank sheet which is the
mind of the man of Nature.
In pattern, his narratives are fictional autobiographies always pretending
to be
"true" stories, and so cleverly
aunthenticated with fictional detail that it is at times difficult to
believe that they have no basis
in actuality.
In general Defoe's sense of
the passing of time in a story is vague and poor. Crusoe's
adventures and Moll Flanders'
love affairs drift on through an excessive number of years.
The relation of Defoe's narratives to the tradition of the English novel has been debated. He has been regarded as following the picaresque type of fiction, and if the word picarsque is loosely used. Defoe wrote rogue biography than the true picaresque. There the tradition as formulated required biographical pattern, episodic structure with the protagonist living by his wits and passing from one social stratum to another from one professional class to another, the object of the change being diversified social expose or satire.
defoe's traditions are clearly those of biography, voyage
literature, and the moral treatise. He lacks power over domestic emotions,
and these were to be the stock in trade of the sentimentalists; but his
gifts are more basically sound than many of theirs, and his influence will
endure as long as theirs. He is perhaps more realistic than many of them
are; but he never seems to worry about conscientious fabrication of real
life: he is like the truly natural storyteller, content to create elaborate
illusions of reality