The
question of why "Alice’s adventures in Wonderland" is one of the most influent
novels in the Anglo-Saxon world is just a highly
topical subject, which is being constantly updated
by distinguished celebrities all around the world. But anyway we can not
grasp the whole meaning of this great work in an overview, and our intention
is just to emphasize the relevant aspects of a novel of this category.
"Alice’s
adventures in Wonderland" is, first of all, a tale for children, a tale
created by Lewis Carroll about a real girl, Alice
Liddell, who was his favourite child. He felt strongly attracted to
her and this was a fundamental fact to understand the whole meaning of
the story and later of the novel. It is thought that Carroll conceived
the plot of the novel the 4th July 1862, when Carroll and the reverend
Robinson Duckworth, who was his friend and colleague in the Trinity
College , went into a excursion along the Thames with the three Liddell
sisters Lorina (13), Alice (10) and Edith (8). That singular day, the little
girls asked Carroll for a tale, and he had to improvise as they insisted
on this. The girls (and particularly Alice) got excited when they
listened to that lovely tale that Carroll was inventing for them. Alice
said that she had never imagined such a beautiful story, and therefore
she asked Carroll to write it to her. Because of this, and thinking that
it was going to be for the girl who had always loved, Carroll gave it to
her for her birthday. Then, 25 years later, when Alice was already married,
he asked her if he could borrow the original copy to publish it. But he
didn't publish exactly the same tale that he had told the Liddell
sisters, but changed some parts which he considered too personal and included
other more appropriate, playing on words and sometimes regarded by
literary experts as better than the ones which are in the original. But
it was a surprise for Carroll. He couldn’t imagine it was going to
be such a big success.
Focusing
now our study on Lewis Carroll’s style it is necessary to mention some
qualities in his work which are typical, like his rapid rhythm,
avoiding always unnecessary words without any clearly-defined function,
using a direct style, introducing the action to the reader, etc.
Carroll places the reader in contact with the action, really near it, making
it possible to identify himself with this new reality Carroll is showing
us. The style of the author allows the reader to feel nearer the action,
though this fact is in contrast with this fantastic world Carroll is showing
us. The author introduces us into the different scenes and elements
with so various resorts. But some of them are described not really in detail.
As we've said, sometimes the author makes us know about the scenes, elements
and characters of the book using short descriptions or even by the dialogues
of the characters themselves. The dream (which practically covers
the whole novel) makes it possible Carroll to avoid objective situations
and therefore he can focus all his work on the subjectivity of Alice. So
Carroll describes a summer afternoon besides the bank, the monotonous walk
of Alice, the sudden appearance of a strange rabbit wearing clothes, a
so deep rabbit hole...
But what the reader is feeling when he is in front of "Alice's Adventures
in Wonderland", is not, indeed, the description of this action, but the
boredom of the child, the slight desperation in front of her older sister’s
world that the little child can’t understand, the contrast between her
feelings and the curiosity for the rabbit with gloves and finally the emotion
of avoiding the reality without any fear to be guided by her instincts.
We can also appreciate her happiness when she decides that and her fear
in that new world where Alice doesn’t feel safe.
The reader feels in a different world, where Alice has come into. Alice
is now shrouded in mystery. The values are not the same, the strange creatures
that are there don’t think the same way Alice thinks, and even Alice undergoes
real metamorphosis in her height. In my opinion that dream is a very
interesting resource which allows Carroll to write more freely .
On the pretext of the dream, Carroll shows us a sequence of characters
which are archetypes, perfect examples of
social situations of Victorian
Culture, but very different if we compare them with the world we are used
to live in. With the same purpose the dramatic strength of Carroll’s characters
is increased through zoological shapes, which provides the author with
more possibilities and sense.
Another
essential points in "Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland" are the psychological
portraits of the characters. Some of them are described rapidly like accidental
characters hardly mentioned, whereas others are described accurately, sometimes
more than Alice herself. We only have to think about characters like the
Hatter, the Queen, etc.
Nevertheless
there is a third kind of specific characters like, for instance "the Cat
of Cheshire", which has been identified with Carroll, who suddenly appear
as if he were spying in the dream that he has invented. Anyway it is necessary
to say that "Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland" is more than a sharp view
of British society ; it’s the view of a little child, Alice, in front of
a incomprehensible and irrational world which suddenly involves her. Now
she will have to get around by herself, without any help. The things that
she learned before, in a different world, don’t have any use now. Though
she'll try to recall the lessons she learned at school, she will realize
that there is no use on doing that. These old lessons seem to have suffered
the same strange transformations that she has, and now they are useless
to any of her purposes.
The
way that Carroll involves real characters into incomprehensible situations
has made some experts compare him and his style with the figure of Kafka.
But the main difference between Lewis Carroll and Kafka is the dynamism,
the fresh impetus which Carroll’s art shows and the great optimism of his
main character, Alice.
This
work, as so many magnificent works of fantasy, is opened to many kinds
of different symbolic interpretation like, for instance, political, Freudian
or metaphysic. But some of the interpretations that have been made about
this work, cannot be considered appropriate and can lead to wrong interpretations.
For instance, Shane
Leslie, in her article about "Lewis Carroll and the
Oxford Movement" (published in the London Mercury , July 1933) said
she had discovered in Alice a secret story about religious disputes in
the Victorian period. She maintained that the jar of marmalade,
for instance, represented the Protestantism
of the Victorian England. The battle between the red and the white king
represented the confrontation between Thomas
Huxley and the bishop
Samuel Wilberforce. The blue caterpillar was Benjamin Jowet; the white
Queen was the cardinal John Henry Newmann, the red queen was the
cardinal Henry Manning, the cat of Cheshire was the cardinal Nicholas
Wiseman, and so on. But if we compare this interpretations with other more
modern studies we will realize that we can find hundreds of them. Possibly
we will not be able to distinguish the better ones if we are not experts
on this field. I have read symbolic interpretations about the cat of Cheshire,
showing that it is Lewis Carroll himself spying in this strange dream.
I am not going to talk about the ones I think are better, but what I mainly
want to show is that we can’t say that one is true and the other is false
and vice versa.
Therefore
I am merely going to say that all them are possible but we can’t be sure
of any of them. In fact, nowadays the most increased interpretations
are the psychoanalystic interpretations. Anyway, though some people
insist on giving to "Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland" lots of symbolic
interpretations, as we have seen before, when children read the book for
first time, although they don’t pay attention to this fact, they enjoy
the book and get excited with the story like Alice Liddell did that famous
summer day, when Carroll told her the tale.
Now,
if you would like to know more about this essay, his purposes and the definitive
result , you we'll have a short explanation if you click here. Final
conclusion.