About six o'clock, just as Harvey
Munden came to the end of his day's work, and grew aware that he was hungry,
some one knocked at the outer door -- a timid knock, signalling a person of no
importance. He went to open, and saw a man whose face he remembered.
'What is it this time?' he asked
good-humouredly.
'Well, sir, I should like, if you will allow
me, to draw your attention to an ingenious little contrivance -- an absolute
cure for smoky chimneys.'
The speaker seemed to be about forty; he was dressed
with painful neatness, every article of his clothing, from hat to boots,
exhibiting some trace of repair. He stood with his meagre form respectfully
bent, on his drawn features a respectful smile, and prepared to open a small
hand-bag -- so strikingly new that it put its bearer to shame. Harvey Munden
observed him, listened to his exposition, and said at length:
'When do you knock off work?'
'Well, sir, this is probably my last call
to-day.'
'Come in for a minute, then. I should like to
have a talk with you.'
Respectfully acquiescent, the man stepped
forward into the comfortable sitting-room, which he surveyed with timid
interest. His host gave him a chair by the fireside, and induced him to talk of
his efforts to make a living. Brightened by the cheeriness of the surroundings,
and solaced by an unwonted sympathy, the hapless struggler gave a very simple
and very lamentable account of himself. For years he had lived on the petty
commission of petty sales, sometimes earning two or three shillings a day, but
more often reckoning the total in pence.
'I'm one of those men, sir, that weren't made
to get on in the world. As a lad, I couldn't stick to anything -- couldn't seem
to put my heart into any sort of work, and that was the ruin of me -- for I had
chances to begin with. I've never done anything to be ashamed of -- unless it's
idleness.'
'You are not married?'
His eyes fell, and his smile faded; he shook
his head. The other watched him for a moment.
'Will you tell me your name? Mine is Munden.'
'Nangle, sir -- Laurence Nangle.'
'Well, Mr Nangle, will you come and dine with
me?'
Abashed and doubtful, the man drew his legs
further beneath the chair and twisted his hat. There needed some pressure
before he could bring himself to accept the invitation; improbable as it
seemed, he was genuinely shy; his stammered phrases and a slight flush on his
cheeks gave proof of it.
They descended together to the street, and
Munden called a hansom; ten minutes drive brought them to the restaurant, where
the host made choice of a retired corner, and quietly gave his directions.
Nangle's embarrassment being still very observable, Munden tried to put him at
ease by talking as to any ordinary acquaintance, of the day's news, of the
commonest topics. It was not possible to explain himself to his guest, to avow
the thought which had prompted this eccentric behaviour; Nangle could not but
regard him with a certain uneasiness and suspicion; but by dint of persistence
in cheerful gossip he gradually fixed the smile upon the face of his shabby
companion, and prepared him to do justice to the repast.
Failure in that respect would not have been due
to lack of appetite. When soup was set before him Nangle's lips betrayed their
watery eagerness; his eyes rolled in the joy of anticipation. Obviously
restraining himself, and anxious not to discredit his host by any show of
ill-breeding, he ate with slow decorum -- though his handling of the spoon
obeyed nature rather than the higher law. Having paused for a moment to answer
some remark of Munden's, he was dismayed by the whisking away of his plate.
'But -- I -- I hadn't finished ----'
The waiter could not be called back, and
Munden, by treating the incident jocosely, made it contribute to his guest's
equanimity. When wine was poured out for him Nangle showed a joyous suffusion
over all his changing countenance; he drew a deep breath, quivered at the lips,
and straightened himself.
'Mr Munden' -- this when he had drunk a glass
-- 'it is years since I tasted wine. And ah! how it does one good! What
medicine is like it?'
'None that I know of,' jested
Nangle laughed for the first time -- a most
strange laugh, suggesting that he had lost the habit, and could not hit a natural
note. Feeling the first attempt to be a failure, he tried again, and his louder
voice frightened him into silence.
'What is your opinion?' asked Munden, smiling
at this bit of character. 'Is it possible for a shy man to overcome the
failing, with plenty of practice?'
'Do you ask that because of anything you have
noticed in me?'
'Well, yes. It rather surprises me, after all
your experience, that you are still unhardened. How do you manage to call at
people's houses and face all sorts of ----'
'Ah! you may well ask! Mr Munden, it's a daily
death to me; I assure you it is. I often stand at a door shaking and trembling,
and can scarcely speak when it opens. I'm the last man to succeed in this kind
of thing; I do it because I can't do anything else. But it's awful, Mr Munden,
awful; and I get no better. I know men who never feel it; they'd laugh in my
face if I spoke of such a thing. But all my life I've suffered from want of
self-confidence. If it hadn't been for that ----'
He broke off to help himself from a dish
offered at his shoulder. The waiter's proximity startled him, and for a few
moments he ate in silence -- ate with manifest hunger, which he did not try to
disguise; for the influences of the fortunate hour had warmed his heart and
were giving him courage. Munden set a fair example, himself no despicable
trencherman. After an entrée of peculiar savour, Nangle found it
impossible to restrain his feelings.
'I never in all my life ate anything so good,'
he murmured across the table.
Munden observed the growth of a new man, born
of succulent food and generous wine. The characteristics of the individual thus
called into being promised amusement; it was clear that they would be amiable
and not unrefined. Semi-starvation and a hated employment had not corrupted the
original qualities of Laurence Nangle; rather, these qualities had been frozen
over, and so preserved. They were now rapidly thawing, and the process, painful
to him at first, grew so enjoyable that delight beamed from his eyes.
At dessert he talked without
self-consciousness, and was led into reminiscence. Munden had chanced to
mention that he was a Yorkshireman.
'And so am I!' exclaimed Nangle; 'so am I. But
I came away when I was a little lad, and I've never been there since. Do you know
'A love affair, I dare say?'
Nangle looked away and slowly nodded several
times. Then he drank with deliberation, and smacked his lips. A glow was
deepening on his hollow cheeks.
'Yes, you are right. I could tell you a strange
thing that happened to me only a few days ago. But, first of all, I should like
to know -- why did you ask me to dine with you?'
'Oh, an inspiration.'
'You thought I looked hungry. Yes, so I was;
and the dinner has done me good. I feel better than I have done for years --
for years. I could tell you a strange thing ----'
He paused, a shade of troublous agitation
passing over the gleam of his countenance. After waiting for a moment Munden
asked whether he smoked.
'When I can afford it, which isn't very often.'
They rose and went to the smoking-room. Nangle's
step had the lightness, the spring of recovered youth. He selected a cigar with
fastidious appreciation; buoyantly he declared for cognac with the coffee. And
presently the stream of his talk flowed on.
'Yes, I had a very good education at a private school
-- a commercial school. You don't know
His eyes grew fixed; the hand in which he held
his cigar fell. A deep sigh, and he continued:
'I believe her father would have helped us, one
way or another; but Mrs Cliffe spoilt all. When it came out, there was a
fearful to-do. Lucy was what you may call rich; at all events, she'd be left
comfortably off some day. As for me -- what prospects had I? Mr Cliffe talked
kindly to me, but he had to send me away. He got me a place in
'She married some one else, no doubt?'
'Yes, she did. And I knew all about it, worse
luck; I'd rather have lost sight of her altogether. She married the brother of
a friend of mine; well, not a friend, but an acquaintance, who was in
The last words were uttered with startling
vehemence. Nangle clenched his fist, and sat stiffly, quivering with
excitement. Munden subdued a smile.
'A long time back, nearly four years, this
fellow Dunning told me that his brother had just died. Lucy was left with her
daughter, the only child she'd had; and they lived at
'Not at present,' remarked the listener. And
truly, for the warm, animated face before him was that of a comparatively young
man.
'Well, I felt bitterly ashamed of myself,
dressed as I was, and peddling from house to house. She kept staring at me, as
if she couldn't get over her astonishment. Had she never heard of me? I asked.
Yes, she had, every now and then. James Dunning had told her I was a commercial
traveller, or something of that kind. Then I asked if she was living here, in
'I hope that isn't the end of the story,' said
Munden, as he cut the tip of a second cigar.
'I only wish it was,' returned his guest,
frowning and straightening himself as before. 'Now, you know something about
me, Mr Munden -- I mean, you can form some notion of the man I am from what I
have told you. And do you think that I could do such a mean thing as go to that
lady - her I call Lucy, for old-time sake - in the hope of getting money from
her? Do you believe it of me?'
'Assuredly not.'
'I thank you for your saying so. It came about
like this. I did a foolish thing. Two days after that meeting I had to be in
Munden reflected. There was silence for a
little.
'Do you suppose,' asked the host at length,
'that Mrs Dunning -- the widowed lady -- regarded you with any such suspicion?'
'Not for one moment,' cried Nangle.
'No? and isn't it possible that you
misunderstood her when you thought she was ashamed of you? From what you have
told me of her character ----'
'Yes,' interrupted the other eagerly, 'no doubt
I was wrong in that. She felt like I did -- a sort of shame, a sort of
awkwardness; but if I had stayed she'd have got over it. I'm sure she would. I
was a fool to bolt like that. It gave James Dunning's wife a chance of thinking
of me as her husband does. It's all my fault.'
'And another thing. You take it for granted
that James Dunning accused you of wanting to beg or borrow from his
sister-in-law. Doesn't it occur to you that he might be afraid of something
else -- something more serious from his point of view?'
'I don't quite understand.'
'Why, suppose that when the widowed lady talked
to him about you she showed a good deal more interest in you than James Dunning
approved? Suppose she even asked for your address, or something of that kind?'
Nangle fixed a gaze on the speaker. His eyes
widened to express an agitating thought.
'You think -- that -- is possible?'
'Well, not impossible.'
'And that fellow -- is afraid -- Lucy might
----'
'Precisely. In all likelihood that would be
very disagreeable to Mr and Mrs James Dunning. She is a widow in easy
circumstances, without children, without near relatives ----'
'You are right!' murmured Nangle slowly. 'I see
it now. That's why he has been afraid of me. And he must have had some reason.
Perhaps she has spoken of me. It seems impossible -- after all these years
----'
He sank back, and stared into vacancy with
glowing eyes.
'In your position,' said Munden, 'I should take
an early opportunity of revisiting Prince of Wales Road.'
'How can I? Think of my poverty! How can
you advise such a thing?'
'It behoves you,' continued the other, with
much gravity, 'to clear your character in the eyes of that lady. In justice to
yourself ----'
'Again you are right! I will go to-morrow.'
'It seems to me that this is a case for
striking while the iron is hot. It's now only eight o'clock, and give me leave
to say that you will never be so able to justify yourself as this evening. A
hansom will take you to Kentish Town in half an hour.'
Nangle started up -- the picture of radiant
resolve.
'I have just half-a-crown in my pocket, and
that's how I'll use it! Thank you! You have made me see things in a new light.
I feel another man! And if I find that what you hinted at is really the case,
shall I hesitate out of false shame? Which is better for Lucy: to live with
those people, always feeling sad and lonesome, or to find a real home with the
man she loved when she was a girl -- the man who has loved her all his life?'
'Bravo! This is the right -- the heroic vein.
In five minutes they had quitted the
restaurant. They found a hansom, and, as he leapt into it, Nangle shouted
gallantly to the driver: 'Prince of Wales Road, Kentish Town!' Impossible to recognize
the voice which but two hours since had murmured respectfully at Harvey
Munden's door. 'Come and see me tomorrow,' Munden called to him, and a hand
waved from the starting cab.
Munden was entertained, and something more.
Partly out of kindness, in part from curiosity, he had given a good dinner to a
poor devil oppressed with ills; he desired to warm the man 5 chilly blood and
to improve its quality; he wished to study the effects of such stirring
influence in this particular case. And it seemed probable that he had achieved
a good deal more than the end in view. It might come to pass that a
good-humoured jest would change incalculably the course of two lives.
It happened that on the morrow he was obliged
to go out of town. On returning late at night he found in his letter-box a
hand-delivered note, with the signature, 'Laurence Nangle.' Only a couple of
lines to say that Nangle had called twice, and that he would come again in a
day or two. 'Yours gratefully,' he wrote himself, which possibly signified the
news Munden hoped for.
Nearly a week went by, and again at six o'clock
Munden was summoned to the door by a knock he recognized. There stood Mr Nangle
-- quantum mutatus! In his hand no commercial bag, but a most respectable
umbrella; on his head an irreproachable silk hat; the rest of his equipment in
harmony therewith. The disappearance of an uncomely beard had struck a decade
from his apparent age; he held himself with a certain modest dignity, and did
not shrink from the scrutiny of astonished eyes.
'Come in! Delighted to see you.'
He entered, and for a moment seated himself,
but his feelings would not allow him to keep a restful position. Starting up
again, he exclaimed:
'Mr Munden, what can a man say when he's in
debt for all that makes life worth living?'
'It depends whether the creditor is man or
woman.'
'In my case, it's both. But if it hadn't been
for you ----'
His voice failed him.
'I was right, was I?'
'Yes, you were right. I'll tell you about it. I
got out of the cab at the end of Prince of Wales Road, and walked to the house.
I knocked at the door. A servant came, and I told her I wished to see Mrs
Dunning -- the widow lady. I'd hardly spoken when James Dunning came out of a
room; he had heard my voice. "What's the meaning of this ?" he said
in his brutal way, pushing up against me. "Didn't you understand me?"
"Yes, I did, and better than you think. I have come to see a lady who
happens to live in your house ----" And just then I saw Lucy herself at
the back of the hall. I brushed past Dunning, and went right up to her.
"Mrs Dunning, I wish to speak to you. Will you let me? Or do you want me
to be turned out of the house like a beggar?" "No, no!" She was
white as a sheet, and held out her hand to me, as if she wanted protection.
"It's all a mistake. You must stay -- I want you to stay!" James's
wife had come forward, and she was staring at me savagely. "Where can we
talk in private ?" I asked; and I didn't let go Lucy's hand. Then, all of
a sudden, Dunning turned about; you never saw such a change in a man.
"Why, Lucy, what's the matter? I thought you didn't wish to see Mr Nangle.
You've altogether misled us." I looked at Lucy, and she was going red --
and then I saw tears in her eyes. "Go into the drawing-room, Nangle,"
said Dunning. "It's all a misunderstanding. We must talk it over
afterwards." So I went into the room, and Lucy came after me, and I shut
the door ----'
He stopped with a choke of emotion.
'Excellent, i' faith,' said Munden beaming.
'Do you suppose,' continued the other, gravely,
'that I could ever have done that if it hadn't been for your dinner? Never!
Never! I should have crept on through my miserable life, and died at last in
the workhouse; when all the time there was a woman whose own happiness depended
on a bit of courage in me. She'd never have dared to show a will of her own;
James Dunning and his wife were too strong for her. Cowards, both of us -- but
I was the worst. And you put a man's heart into me. Your dinner -- your wine --
your talk! If I hadn't gone that night, I should never have gone at all --
never!'
'I knew that.'
'But what I can't understand is -- why
did you ask me to dine with you? Why? It's like what they call the finger of
Providence.'
'Yes. As I told you -- it was an inspiration.'
(English Illustrated Magazine, 1895)
(Provided by Mitsuharu Matsuoka, Nagoya
University, Japan,
on 18 October 1997.)