tension among
the spontaneous thing and that projected is decided.
Anyway, although Robinson
Crusoe was inspired by other stories, Defoe transforms Crusoe into
a new character and of a great verisimilitude. This is comprehensible keeping
in mind the temperament of Defoe. As few biographies, Defoe's biography
denotes before anything an innate easiness to adapt to people and situations
until the point of losing his identity. It is almost a vocation in him
that desire for double game. Sign of this are also some of their writings
in which, for example, The Poor Man's Plea, 1698, he adopts the
voice of a humble citizen, or in The Shortest Way with Dissenters,
1702, he adopts the voice a high clergyman of the Anglican Church. In the
case of Robinson Crusoe so perfect belongs the adaptation from the author
to his character that the identification between both characters became
in its day one of the common places for the critics. It seems comprehensible
that the truthfulness that Crusoe acquires is partly due to that Robinson
Crusoe is made up with many elements of Defoe, although another point one
would have to affirm on purpose of Moll Flanders; for example. But it is
extremely imprecise transforming these likeness into identities, since
they are many of the features of Defoe's biography that are radically inapplicable
to Robinson Crusoe.
It doesn't fit doubt
that the first responsible that during a lot of time he has been carried
out this critical simplification is the same Defoe who in Serious Reflections
during the Life of Robinson Crusoe suggests that the history of Crusoe
is an allegory of his own life. It is possible that being like Defoe was
of puritan convictions, felt the necessity to justify a literary work carried
out primarily with ends guided to entertain and to have a good time, and
was forced to interpret his work and his own life from a moral perspective.
In many aspects Defoe is very different from Robinson Crusoe. To check
it there is not more than to compare the attitudes of both in front of
many questions, some as significant and critical as can be the slavery,
the woman's position in the social life, the importance of the family for
the individual. And they are not only different great part of his ideas.
Defoe doesn't share the elementary things of Robinson Crusoe, and his temperament
is not prosaic as his invented character's one. Although, as Shakespeare,
Defoe didn't come from the noble class, but
[ 1
] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4
] [ 5 ] [ 6
] [ 7 ] [ 8 ] [ 9
] [ 10 ] [ 11 ] [ 12
] [ 13 ]
[ Next
]
[ Back ]
Academic
Year 00-01
07/02/2001
©a.r.e.a.
Dr. Vicente Forés López
©Ana
Aroa Alba Cuesta
Universitat
de València Press